☆ Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places ☆ Paul Collier ☆ Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places ☆ Paul Collier - Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places, Wars Guns and Votes Democracy in Dangerous Places Wars Guns and Votes Paul Collier investigates the violence and poverty in the small remote countries at the lowest level of the world economy An esteemed economist and a foremost authority on deve ☆ Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places ☆ Paul Collier - Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places, Wars Guns and Votes Democracy in Dangerous Places Wars Guns and Votes Paul Collier investigates the violence and poverty in the small remote countries at the lowest level of the world economy An esteemed economist and a foremost authority on deve
☆ Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places ☆ Paul Collier, Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places, Paul Collier, Wars Guns and Votes Democracy in Dangerous Places Wars Guns and Votes Paul Collier investigates the violence and poverty in the small remote countries at the lowest level of the world economy An esteemed economist and a foremost authority on developing countries Collier argues that the spread of elections and peace settlements in the world s most dangerous countries may lead to a brave new.
☆ Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places ☆ Paul Collier - Wars, Guns, and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places, Wars Guns and Votes Democracy in Dangerous Places Wars Guns and Votes Paul Collier investigates the violence and poverty in the small remote countries at the lowest level of the world economy An esteemed economist and a foremost authority on deve
Excellent until the recommendation section where Collier seems to ignore how he s set out politician s motivations and makes suggestions that don t quite add up in my opinion
Paul Collier asserts the 21st century being the era of civil wars If the claim is practically solidified, the peaceful restoration of a world community will be a far fetched dream Civil wars are detrimental to political and state progression, let alone humanity A volatile umbrella sheltering ethnic discrepancies, power related violence, abusive exploitation of developmental funds, brutality, genocide and the biggest scare of all thriving of terrorists pockets Collier, an expert in developmental [...]
nwhytevejournal 1447888mlWars, Guns and Votes is a lucidly written analysis of the effects and causes of democracy and good governance in the poorest countries of the world, whose inhabitants Collier describes in a previous book as the bottom billion Collier s findings are disturbing and provocative, but based on good hard research He states that 1 democratic poor countries are at risk of violence than non democratic poor countries for rich countries, the opposite is the case 2 This is because [...]
A really interesting and surprisingly readable book Paul Collier has a delightful way of expressing ideas so that they are witty and comprehensible at the same time He makes reference to a lot of the research that he has done, without overloading us with unreadable academic jargon I suppose this might frustrate a serious reader, but it made the book accessible for me I do not know about economics or politics to be able to judge whether his ideas are reasonable or not, but in any case, they prov [...]
Response to both Amy Chua in World On Fire and Paul Collier in War, Guns and Votes my views on their criticism of how the developed world has tried to build democracies in failed and fragile states, how their opinions agree, how they differ.Amy Chua and Paul Collier share some penetrating insights into the problems associated with the spread of democracy since the early 1990s in their respective works, World on Fire and War, Guns and Votes At the forefront of their analyses is the contention tha [...]
Economic researcher meets social commentator and produces a 2009 published work of wonderful theory as to why democracy fails for the bottom billion economically placed people of the world Read with a mindset of when it was published it is a riveting read and journey through the authors reasoning for the theories presented and conclusions drawn As he says himself, past theories he once positioned he has now moved on, which would make an assessment and modern day addition to this book an equally [...]
Interesting, but very mass appeal instead of in depth Doesn t talk about democracy as much as it talks about dictatorships and instability But if you want a starting point for African state building mainly , it s an easy read.
I ve owned this book almost since it came out in 2009 but only got around reading it now Although the world has in many respects moved on in the intervening six years, Collier s arguments regarding democracy in dangerous places are still valid Unfortunately Collier relies mostly on quantitative studies conducted by himself and his graduate students to provide evidence on topics related to democratic challenges and conflict in the bottom billion a term he coined in his earlier book about the poor [...]
I come not to praise Paul Collier and not really to bury him but to point out what I feel are some flaws in this very highly praised book First of all it is too popular by half He leaves out all of the research that went into his book he describes some of the difficulties he and his indefatigable band of international Ph.D candidates had in finding data and in constructing experiments that worked and then has a list of the original research he used More method and less description of outcomes wo [...]
My summary of the book benhabiles 2017 02 boo
Interesting book asking very relevant questions on democracy and development of least developed countries I learned a lot Some of it is outdated though, due to the current terrorist threat, different from civil wars, coups, etc due to which LDC governments are increasing their security and army expenditures, often supported by donors.
If I could give the book 3.5 stars I would If you ve read Bottom Billion highly recommended , then I don t think you ll necessarily get much out of War, Guns, Votes This time around Collier is focused on the political economy of the bottom billion, but his analysis and recommendations echo Bottom Billion to a large degree.The book has been successful in stirring up interesting blog post reviews, which I think do a good job explaining the good and the bad about the book 1 Bill Easterly is right [...]
Thoroughly and rigorously researched without doubt and heavily loaded with christian and capitalist sentiments as well The writer seems to have forgotten completely or feign ignorance that there s no altruism in politics In order to justify his case of ethnic political crisis using Nigeria as case study, the writer made mistake or twisted deliberately the Patricia Etteh money laundering scandal Here is the anecdote Patricia Etteh the house speaker was reported to have spent over 600 million nair [...]
Interesting read The book starts by giving a description of daily life politics at the bottom billion He subsequently analyses the threats guns, wars and coups The insights gains in the analyses then provide a framework to assess how the international community could intervene to provide the essentials necessary o get on the tracks for peace i.e to introduce accountability and security as public goods The final chapter consists of 3 proposals of potential intervention that could help the bottom [...]
While the book addresses many interesting themes based on extensive research, the books fails to address how these economies were divided and concurred for many years The British regime was one that controlled a country for many years sucked its resources, left its people uneducated, handed the throne to a dictator and left a mess behind The acts of colonization have caused a chaos in Africa.Africa is made up of many tribes and to instill ethnicity and bais in the hearts of those people creates [...]
I had relatively high hopes for this book 1.5 Needless to say, my expectations were not met Collier s main argument in this book is that elections by themselves where not the solution to violence and civil war Most of the book is spent discussing reasons for violence and some case examples Lastly, he presents his own solution that seems highly immature and impractical with the underlying assumption that everything will work out in the end if institutions can work His easy solution could only wor [...]
I would strongly recommend this book to anyone who gives a damn about poverty in Africa Collier offers fascinating data that is used to tell an interesting story of the poverty traps described in his previous book The Bottom Billion Much of his thesis resonates with current events, the 2013 Zimbabwe election called for Robert Mugabe and ZANU PF is a case in point.There are some irritations Collier occasionally leaps to positions based on his belief in growth and not entirely substantiated by his [...]
Encompasses interesting research about the relationships between democracy, demographics, economics, and war in the 3rd world Collier seems to really know his stuff in this space and does a good job at pointing out research done by others, and the flaws in his own work I thought the most interesting conclusion from the book was that the likelihood of an outbreak in war can be accurately modeled based solely on the feasibility of war availability of guns, mountainous regions to hide in, etc That [...]
It took me reading the entire book to understand what the argument was getting at until the last 30 pages or so, I couldn t really understand how it all tied together There are a lot of brilliant concepts in this book, but the author s descriptions of the various methodologies are kind of awkward, and the examples are a little unfocused and all over the place Also, a lot of the book is already out of date I hope there is an update reflecting recent trends in UN peacekeeping If you re really inte [...]
I highly enjoy Collier s style of writing and the research he presents in his writing I ve never read one of the primary papers he references in this work or the Bottom Billion, but he referes to many studies he and colleagues have completed and published in the book This focuses on how policies could be enacted to improve stability and accountability in the poorest countries There are many interesting findings that make this work worth reading, including that democracy is actually negatively co [...]
The Bottom Billion was great in bringing actual data into the study of the poor instead of hope or cynicism Now, Collier goes into my primary interest, the juxtaposition of development, violence, and democracy The truth is uglier than those who advocate military intervention to save the world want and also clearer than what isolationists hope for Great book by a rare academic who jumps from hard statistical analysis and game theory to a running narrative of what the self interested dictator ough [...]
Unless you are really interested in Post conflict conflict countries and international development in them, this book can seem than just a bit academic The amount of proving and reproving could get boring for anyone who isnt really interested.But if you are interested even remotely in this then pick it up And pick it up yesterday This book is a must have for those who wish to go into the field, and I feel that it may already be a text book for some classes.Even though he sticks mainly with Afri [...]
To be honest, this is of a literature review on peacebuilding and the relationship between democracy and conflict, and is for the sake of non academics who are less experienced in the subject matter This doesn t render the whole thing pointless, however Collier s points about the manner in which elections are treated as a panacea to conflict are not new, though his suggestions of an international system of checks and balances to encourage elections by providing a credible security guarantee to [...]
Much like The Bottom Billion I found this book rather frustrating While I agree that changes need to be made in the provision of foreign aid, and I don t agree with Sachs that it s simply that we need to throw a ton of money at the problem, I think Collier s proposed solutions are incredibly unrealistic He s an economist, which I love, but his solutions are things that are completely unfeasible politically Without taking into account what is actually possible politically suggestions like this ar [...]
Are the world s poorest countries too big to be nations but too small to be states The explanation and analysis Mr Collier provides of the problems with democracy and accountability in the poorest countries is interesting and depressing albeit not terribly surprising He dispassionately uses statistics to try to establish the common factors around civil wars and coups, with mildly depressing results.His conclusions are interesting, but I m not convinced by how practical his suggested solutions ar [...]
I think I m just not as big of fan of Collier s writing style His arguments are based on a large amount of statistical research carried out in partnership with PhD candidates definitely well entrenched academia It may have helped to have first read his first book, The Bottom Billion If you are interested in post conflict reconstruction or conflict prevention, this would be a great resource.
Lots of interesting ideas as Collier builds up his ideas from Bottom Billion He is not afraid to take an unpopular opinion such as that European colonialism in Africa was not all bad news , but many of his proposed solutions include international interventionism on some scale I would have been interested in seeing solutions for Africa and the rest of the fragile states described that would promote change from within on a sustainable level.
The author of the Bottom Billion continues to analyze the hot spots of the world using economics and statistics to investigate such questions as why AK 47s are so cheap in Africa, how dictators use elections to perpetuate themselves AND aid donations, military spending unconsciously matches perceptions of dangerous neighbors, judging the efficacy of arms embargoes by studying the stock values of arms companies hint if they re making money, the embargo isn t working.
Paul Collier shows us why the promises of elections by themselves where not the secret elixir to save the poor countries from constant violence and civil war He goes on to identify what are the causes behind violence in the bottom billion and why easy solutions have failed in the past In the end, though, he presents his own easy solution that seems as likely to work as all the ones that he analyzes in the book.
2013 01 04 I appreciated the lack of economic jargon in this book and found the explanation regarding how the research was conducted to be very interesting It is easy to read for the lay person and a good introduction to recent events in various African countries I will definitely look for of his books in the future.